Listen right here

Mary & Blake discuss listener feedback for Outlander Season 8 Episode 8, “In The Forest.”

After the emotional chaos of Episode 8.07, the fandom finally got a chance to breathe. Episode 8.08 felt like classic Outlander again for a lot of listeners: family at the Ridge, Jamie and William finally facing the wound between them, Roger actually working, and Ron Moore’s writing reminding everyone why this show can still hit when it slows down and lets people be human.

Outlander Season 8 Episode 8 Listener Feedback

In this listener feedback episode, we get into your reactions to “In The Forest,” including why Jamie and William’s hug wrecked so many people, why Fanny hearing the buzzing has everyone nervous, and why Lord John walking into yet another trap this late in the season has the fandom asking one very fair question: what are we doing?

We also revisit the lingering fallout from Fergus’s death, whether Marsali leaving the Ridge makes any practical sense, why Frank’s “Deadeye” reveal works emotionally even if the mechanics are doing a lot of volunteer labor, and whether the show is trying to serve the parent story or build an Outlander universe before the main series has fully landed the plane.

Also In This Episode

• Why “Ratings are for shows that don’t break your trust” may be the quote of the season.
• Why so many listeners felt Ronald D. Moore helped get the show back on track.
• Jamie and William’s forest scene, the hug, and the father-son material people have been waiting for.
• Fanny possibly being a time traveler and whether the mythology is getting too crowded.
• Listener theories about Faith, Fanny, and a possible future spin-off.
• Why Marsali rebuilding the printshop works emotionally, even if leaving the Ridge feels questionable.
• Frank, Brianna, Jamie, and the “Deadeye” reveal.
• The ongoing frustration around Lord John, Percy, and Richardson.
• Mary reading Apple Podcast reviews and taking emotional damage in real time.
• Tuna melts, Chantilly cake, Mr. Feeney, Lord of the Flies, and the dangers of bad reviews.

Join The Nerd Clan

Want even more Outlander coverage? Join The Nerd Clan for bonus breakdowns, Blake’s craft-heavy Knee Jerk Reactions, extra analysis, and all the conversations we cannot fit into the main feed.

Join us at JoinTheNerdClan.com.

Follow Mary & Blake

Follow Mary & Blake on Facebook, join our Outlander Cast Facebook Group, and follow us on Instagram and X.

Subscribe to the podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Tell Us Your Kilt Rating

What did you think of Outlander Season 8 Episode 8, “In The Forest”? Did Jamie and William’s reconciliation work for you? Is Fanny really a time traveler? And are you nervous about what the final two episodes still need to pay off?

Drop your Kilt Rating and let us know.

Slàinte Mhath. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿