Skip to content
Explore the app ↗
EXPLAINER

Why Did Theo Kill (SPOILER) in The Rings of Power? Episode 4 Explained

why did theo kill arondir

Full spoilers for The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 4, “Gundabad.”

Yes, Arondir dies in The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 4, “Gundabad,” and Theo is the person who kills him. Theo, now serving Sauron as one of the Nazgnagôl, removes his helmet during the escape from the Orc fortress. Arondir tries to persuade the young man to remove his Ring and leave with him. Sauron orders Theo to kill his former protector, and Theo drives his blade into Arondir. The scene establishes Sauron’s influence over Theo while leaving room for an uncomfortable question: how much of the choice still belongs to Theo?

This death hurts because Arondir has been trying to find Theo for years, and because Theo was the son of Bronwyn, the woman Arondir loved. What began as an uneasy connection between an Elven soldier and a Southlander gradually became a surrogate father-son relationship. When they reunite at Gundabad, those years of love and resentment collide in an instant.

Who Kills Arondir in “Gundabad”?

The direct answer is Theo, played by Tyroe Muhafidin. During the desperate escape from Gundabad, Arondir, Galadriel, Celeborn and Marnûkh face Sauron’s forces. A masked Ring-servant confronts Arondir, and the reveal makes clear that the figure beneath the armor is Theo. Sauron wants Galadriel and Celeborn; Theo initially tells Arondir to walk away, suggesting that a peaceful exit is still possible for the Elf.

Arondir refuses the escape. He asks Theo to take off the Ring and insists that they leave together. The older Elf has already lost Bronwyn, and abandoning her son again is the one outcome he cannot accept. Sauron then appears and issues the fatal command. Theo complies, and the episode closes on the aftermath of Arondir’s death as Galadriel and Celeborn escape.

Is Theo Being Mind-Controlled by Sauron?

The show has not fully defined the balance between magical compulsion and personal responsibility. Theo’s Ring is plainly affecting him, and his hand seems to tremble as Sauron approaches. Yet the series is depicting an early stage of Sauron’s servants: the One Ring has yet to be forged, and the Nine bearers have not completed their transformation into the ghostly Ringwraiths of the Third Age.

Theo actor Tyroe Muhafidin told People that the early Ring-bearers still possess autonomy. In a separate interview with TV Insider, he connected Theo’s action to years of accumulated anger at Arondir, while acknowledging the Ring’s influence. Arondir actor Ismael Cruz Córdova offered a different interpretation of the moment, arguing that Sauron’s direct presence greatly narrows Theo’s freedom.

I find that disagreement fascinating because it describes the tension the scene is trying to dramatize. A person can be manipulated through a genuine grievance, and magical power can amplify a desire that already exists. The storytelling challenge is making the final movement from hesitation to violence clear enough for us to understand the cost of the choice. The moment works emotionally, even as the exact extent of Sauron’s control remains unresolved.

Why Is Theo Angry at Arondir?

Theo grew up in the Southlands under the watch of the Elves, who kept his people under military surveillance because of their ancestors’ allegiance to Morgoth. Arondir was part of that system before his love for Bronwyn changed his relationship to the community. Theo therefore carries complicated feelings toward the man who helped protect his mother and who also represented the authority he resented.

Bronwyn’s death intensifies that fracture. Theo loses the person who gave him a sense of belonging, and the years separating Seasons 2 and 3 create more distance between him and Arondir. Sauron’s offer of power provides an answer to the grievance Theo has struggled to articulate: he wants control over a life in which other people have repeatedly decided his fate. The Ring feeds that desire and places the promised freedom under Sauron’s authority.

That contradiction is central to his tragedy. In reaching for independence, Theo places himself within a hierarchy where obedience becomes an increasingly violent requirement. The finale of “Gundabad” forces him to demonstrate loyalty by destroying the person who most wants to bring him home.

Why Doesn’t Arondir Escape With Galadriel and Celeborn?

Arondir makes a deliberate decision to stay. He helps protect the escape and confronts the figure blocking their path, then recognizes Theo and refuses to abandon him. Cruz Córdova has explained in an interview that Arondir sees the possibility of death yet commits to protecting the others and facing his former charge.

From a storytelling perspective, that is what finally gives Arondir’s long-running relationship with Theo a definitive dramatic consequence. A character’s deepest loyalty creates a difficult choice, and Arondir follows that loyalty even when it costs his life. The decision also leaves a wound in Theo’s story that future episodes can explore. Every act of power Theo performs now carries the memory of the man he killed.

Is Arondir Really Dead? Could He Return?

As of Episode 4, the series presents Arondir’s death as final, and the actor’s interviews discuss his departure as the end of his character’s story. Fantasy can revisit departed characters in memories or visions, but there is currently no confirmed onscreen resurrection or return. Treating the ending as a real loss gives Theo’s action the gravity the scene is built to deliver.

Theo’s eventual identity is a different unresolved question. His new status as a Nazgnagôl makes him a plausible future Ringwraith, while the show has not confirmed that he becomes the Witch-king of Angmar. We maintain the separate theory and evidence in our Theo/Witch-king explainer.

What Arondir’s Death Means for the Rest of Season 3

The death shifts the season from a war measured through armies to a war measured through damaged relationships. Sauron gains power by exploiting Theo’s hurt and by compelling a public proof of allegiance. Arondir dies trying to preserve the bond that might have given Theo another way forward. That creates an emotional reason to follow Theo’s future choices beyond the mystery of which Nazgûl he might become.

For our deeper reaction to this scene, its resemblance to the Han Solo and Kylo Ren confrontation in The Force Awakens, and the episode’s larger craft choices, read our full “Gundabad” Knee-Jerk Reaction. You can also catch up through the Rings of Power Season 3 episode guide.

Related Coverage

By nerds, for nerds. Pull up a chair.More shows and movies coverage ↗

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *